The Belgian Data Protection Authority ('Belgian DPA') reprimanded a property management company (the controller) for unlawfully keeping an employee's email inbox active for an excessive amount of time after the termination of the employment. According to a case-by-case assessment a period of three months would have been appropriate.
What happened?
A former employee of the property management company who was responsible for managing 30 residential buildings, was dismissed in October 2020 without notice. After the termination, the employer kept the employee's professional email address active, claiming it was necessary to ensure a smooth transition of duties. The former employee requested the deactivation of the email and erasure of data under GDPR but received no response. The issue was escalated to the Data Protection Authority (Belgian DPA), which found that the employer violated GDPR by keeping the email address active for an excessive period and failing to respond to the data subject's request.
The Data Protection Authority (DPA) determined that the email address of a former employee qualifies as personal data under GDPR (Article 4(1)). The DPA ruled that the property management company violated GDPR by keeping the email address active for over five months after the employee’s departure, contrary to the principle of purpose limitation (Article 5(1)(b)). While the property management company could have a legitimate interest (Article 6(1)(f)) to retain the email temporarily, the prolonged retention was deemed excessive and contrary to data minimisation principles. Additionally, the DPA found violations of GDPR for not responding to the employee's data erasure request. Consequently, the DPA issued a reprimand to the property management company.
What does this mean for your organisation?
This case highlights the importance of adhering to the GDPR when handling personal data after an employee leaves your organisation. Specifically, it highlights the need to deactivate email accounts promptly after employment ends, activate automatic replies to inform contacts, and provide alternative communication methods. While a short delay for operational reasons may be acceptable, extended retention of an email account can violate GDPR principles, leading to legal repercussions. Organisations must also respond to data erasure requests in a timely manner to avoid further violations and penalties.
Below we have listed some of the best practices your organisation can implement to avoid a similar situation:
Prompt Deactivation of Accounts: Deactivate email accounts and other access permissions immediately upon the termination of employment. This helps prevent unauthorised access and misuse of the former employee’s data. Develop a standardised offboarding procedure that includes immediate account deactivation as a core step.
Automatic Replies and Notifications: Set up automatic email replies to inform contacts that the employee is no longer with the organisation. The reply should include alternative contact information. Automate the setup of out-of-office replies for all departing employees and ensure that these notifications are updated promptly.
Data Minimisation and Retention: Ensure that any retention of personal data, including email addresses, is strictly limited to what is necessary for operational purposes. Avoid keeping data longer than required. In line with the principle of storage limitation, review and update your data retention policies regularly.
Handling Data Erasure Requests: Respond to data erasure requests (under Article 17 GDPR) promptly and within the required timeframe[A.1] c. Ensure that all personal data is deleted or anonymised as requested. Establish clear procedures for managing and responding to data subject requests, and provide training to staff on GDPR compliance and data handling.
Employee Training and Awareness: Provide ongoing training for employees on GDPR requirements and the importance of data protection. Ensure that everyone understands their role in maintaining compliance. Develop a comprehensive training program that includes scenarios and best practices related to data protection, with regular updates as regulations or company policies change.
Implementing Data Protection Policies: Develop and enforce data protection policies that outline how personal data should be handled, including protocols for data access, retention, and deletion. Ensure that data protection policies are easily accessible to all employees and that compliance is monitored and enforced through regular reviews and updates.
Tales from the coalface
Each month, we examine pressing Data Protection issues encountered by our clients. This month we looked at queries associated with implementing effective data deletion and retention policies. These policies are crucial for ensuring compliance with data protection regulations[A.1] , yet many organisations struggle with the complexities of balancing legal requirements with operational needs.
Understanding the Importance of Data Deletion and Retention Policies
Data deletion and retention policies serve as the foundation for managing the lifecycle of personal and sensitive data within an organisation. These policies define how long data should be kept, when it should be deleted, and how it should be securely disposed of. The primary goal is to ensure that data is not kept longer than necessary, reducing the risk of data breaches, minimising storage costs, and maintaining compliance with legal and regulatory requirements. However, the complexities involved in managing data across multiple systems, departments, and jurisdictions can make the implementation of these policies far from straightforward.
Challenges in Implementing Data Deletion and Retention Policies
Inconsistent Data Handling Across Systems: Many organisations operate multiple systems and databases, often inherited from legacy infrastructure or acquired through mergers and acquisitions. Ensuring consistent application of data retention and deletion policies across these systems can be challenging. Discrepancies in data handling procedures may lead to data being retained longer than necessary or prematurely deleted, both of which can have serious legal implications.
Lack of Clear Policy Guidelines: Without clear and detailed guidelines, employees may struggle to understand the specifics of data retention and deletion practices. This can result in inconsistent application of policies, particularly in large organisations where data management responsibilities are distributed across different teams. Furthermore, the lack of a centralised data governance strategy can lead to confusion and errors in data handling.
Difficulties in Managing Unstructured Data: Unstructured data—such as emails, documents, and multimedia files—poses a unique challenge in data deletion and retention. Unlike structured data, which is neatly organised in databases, unstructured data is often scattered across various platforms, making it difficult to identify and manage according to retention policies. This complexity increases the risk of non-compliance and data breaches.
Technical Limitations and Costs Implementing effective data deletion and retention policies often requires significant investment in technology and infrastructure. Legacy systems may not support automated data deletion, necessitating costly upgrades or replacements. Additionally, organisations may face challenges in securely deleting data to ensure it cannot be recovered, particularly in cloud environments.
Compliance with Legal Requirements Organisations can operate in multiple countries and as such have the added challenge of complying with varying legal requirements regarding data retention and deletion. Different jurisdictions may have different rules for how long data should be retained and the specific conditions under which it must be deleted.
Best Practices for Overcoming These Challenges
Conduct a Comprehensive Data Audit: Begin by conducting a thorough audit of your data landscape. Identify where personal and sensitive data is stored, how it is used, and the systems involved. This will provide a clear picture of the data that needs to be managed and help in identifying any gaps or inconsistencies in current practices. A case study conducted by PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) showed that organisations that regularly audit their data holdings were better equipped to align their retention policies with GDPR requirements.
Develop Clear, Detailed Policies: Ensure that your data deletion and retention policies are clear, detailed, easy to understand and accessible to all employees. Include specific guidelines on how to handle data across different systems and provide training to ensure that everyone understands their responsibilities.
Implement Automated Data Management Tools: Where possible, invest in data management tools that can automate the enforcement of data retention and deletion policies. Automation reduces the risk of human error and ensures that policies are applied consistently across all systems. According to a survey by Gartner, organisations that invest in automated data governance solutions see a reduction in potential GDPR violations by up to 40%.
Regularly Review and Update Policies Data protection regulations and business needs evolve over time, so it’s essential to regularly review and update your data deletion and retention policies. Policies and procedures should be adjusted as necessary to stay compliant with legal requirements and to address any emerging challenges.
Ensure Cross-Border Compliance For those organisations who operate in multiple jurisdictions, it’s crucial to stay informed about the data protection laws in each country. Work with data protection experts to ensure that your policies and procedures comply with all relevant regulations, and consider implementing region-specific guidelines where necessary.
Implementing effective data deletion and retention policies is a complex but essential task for any organisation that handles personal and sensitive data. By addressing the challenges outlined above and adopting best practices, organisations can enhance their data governance frameworks, reduce risks, and ensure compliance with data protection regulations.
If you’re unsure where to start or need assistance in developing and implementing a comprehensive data protection training program, please contact Ambit Compliance. Our experts are here to help you navigate the complexities of data protection and create a strong foundation of compliance within your organisation.
Contributors to this blog:
Gillian Traynor and Dwayne Morgan

